Visit Broke Amateurs

Full Review

A.K. Anderson 

By: A.K. Anderson
Number of Reviews: 1184
Average Score: 66

Heads Up!
This review is outdated. Information may be inaccurate.

There are a lot of things people can do for money, but it seems to me that an easy thing any hard-up babe can do is porn. Although, that could be due to the fact that I look at porn sites all day. Regardless, today I have a really good site to recommend called Broke Amateurs.

The funny thing is that in all the videos I watched on BrokeAmateurs (and I watched quite a few), the babe's financial situation never came up. The scenes are true amateur action and there is lots of fun and playful talking before and after the sex (sometimes also during) between the chick and the guy doing all the filming and fucking. They talk about sex and their lives and their experiences and if they are married or seeing someone, etc, but not about money.

At this point, there are 231 videos and they are updating once a week. I do have to say that the POV filming isn’t always the best as the camera is sometimes too close or shaky. Also, the quality can vary depending on the file. However, the newer files and the majority of the older ones offer good-quality playback. The amateur chicks are totally engaging and fun to hang out with for those 20 to 70 minutes.

The site has undergone a redesign since our last visit and while I'd like to say that it's for the better, they haven't imported all of the content yet. Right now, only 66 scenes are in the more user-friendly version, so if you want to view the rest of them, you have to visit the older version. Another issue you might have is that the download button for the videos in the newer section opens up the file in your own video player, unlike the older version which actually lets you save the file.

There are photo sets, but they aren't obvious. First you have to go to the blog and from there you will find links to photo sets spread out among the various posts. Not all the posts have some, but you can filter entries to just include ones with pics in them, which gets you 60 sets overall.

I would recommend reading the blog anyway, as it is actually pretty informative and interesting in its own right. You can also check out some bonus scenes from third-party sites in the "friends" section. The "channels" section just lets you search by category and isn't a bonus feed section.

The guy behind the site saw that there were some chicks he was in contact with who wanted to go on cam, but not do hardcore, so he started another site, Girls Going Solo, dedicated to amateur chicks posing and masturbating and you get access to it.

I have to say that even with the somewhat amateur POV camerawork, I really enjoyed the content. The babes all have their own personalities and the scenes do as well. Fans of true amateur babes doing porn for the first time (or almost the first time) will find something to enjoy on Broke Amateurs.

Member Area Screenshots

  • Screenshot 1
  • Screenshot 2
  • Screenshot 3
  • Screenshot 4

Write Your Review

* Please include a pro and a con about the site. Balance is essential in making a comment worthwhile. Scores without comments will be deleted.

* Watch out for ratings of zero and 100. In our opinion, there is no such thing as a site that is absolutely perfect or completely worthless.

Remaining characters:  

Latest Comments

  • Comment by: Big.Ben

    Score: 85% Date: 02/19/2015

    This was a truly great site, but it isn't updating anymore. However, if you never joined, I would join and download everything. Personally, I really like amateurs. All the fake moaning in professional vids on most other sites really doesn't do anything for me. All the women in this site swallow, so if you are into that, it is great.

  • Comment by: trevrep

    Score: 30% Date: 01/04/2015

    It's a shame that this site doesn't have new content. It used to be my favourite site, and in a world of torrents, I was more than happy to pay to be a member. If there was new content, I'd sign up again in a heart beat.

    That said, if you've not seen any of the stuff before, you'd certainly enjoy it for a brief period.

    If anyone knows if any of the girls have gone on to do anything else, I'd love to know. I've just watched the Tanya anal scene again, I hope to god that girl did some other stuff.

  • Comment by: doc mac

    Score: 40% Date: 12/18/2014

    I joined 10 days ago after a few years and I was very dissappointed. The old content is gone and by far the old girls were better.I signed up for a month and will not continue with the subscription. As paying customers, we deserve better.

  • Comment by: yoshiatsu

    Score: 45% Date: 07/22/2014

    I'll echo Robert Norman's statement that something questionable is up with the site now. It claims to have new girls, but they aren't updating it anymore (just recycling the same videos). From what I can tell, it is and it isn't a fraud. It is a fraud because it isn't providing what is advertised (new girls regularly updated). At the same time, I can tell the site is no longer being administered. I can get to the videos by being a bit sneaky (while signed in) and using unpublished URLs to see all the videos. With a list of all the girls that have been on the site, I have been able to find and download what they've made available that way. That said, it is impossible to get full quality downloads of all the videos. It's a shame that the site has gone dormant. I emailed them about it, but got no response.

  • Comment by: robert norman

    Score: 15% Date: 03/30/2014

    Rabbit should warn customers that this site is a fraud.
    Years ago it was a hot site with some great amateur
    action. Now it is virtually impossible to download from,
    most of the old content is gone! The excuse listed in the
    blog was that some poor girl was outed to her family for
    getting nasty on video. Surprise, surprise, it is the internet!
    Like some of the bad tattoos I see, its not going to go away.
    If this a concern, then counseling should be offered before the shoot is done! As it is this site will get no more from me!
    I already have the good stuff stored on disk!
    Reply from RabbitsReviews (Date:03/31/2014): Thanks for the comment, Robert. You didn't leave an email. If you have been scammed by the site, please contact us with full details and we'll investigate further.

  • Comment by: Tatsu

    Score: 20% Date: 02/15/2014

    Like others here I was member previously and it was a great site however it's now gone to the dogs. Lots of girls now missing (Some of my favourite vids). I would consider staying a member for say $10 but certainly no more than that.

  • Comment by: Strong

    Score: 50% Date: 01/29/2014


    I have left this site for a year now and the comments are the same with updated dates.... I left the site due to an attempt to repeat old vidoes as new... I see nothing has changed... It is a shame, this use to be one the best true amateur sites...

  • Comment by: HardTexan

    Score: 50% Date: 11/09/2013

    I've subscribed several times in the past and have always been happy with the new (sometimes new-ish) girls he finds and gets to go on camera. I was considering re-upping today when I decided to check the reviews here and now I think I won't unless anybody can confirm he's back to cranking out new content. As others have said, it's sad since this used to be one of the best sites out there. I'd have given it 80 or 90 before but after the other reviews it's a 50. Moving on in the hopes he gets his shit together and starts updating again.

  • Comment by: Buddybear

    Score: 40% Date: 10/16/2013

    Pros are the women are real amateurs and not staged, but the Con is very little new videos was a member a year ago and nothing seems new with a lot of older vids that I remember nowhere to be found.

  • Comment by: 343

    Score: 60% Date: 09/20/2013

    Very disappointed. I had been a member in the past and decided to re-join. MANY of the old videos have disappeared, hard drive crash??? come on. I hope they have recovered some or what not. Hate to say it, but it seems like this site has become the way that many non-studio start-up become (based on reading other reviews) starts off excellent for about 2 or so years, then the webmaster gets lazy, made enough money, and takes off, or makes very seldom updates--likely just picking out off the archives. On the bright side...There is still some good content, models are hot! and look hot yet pretty ordinary, like a girl you'd sit next to in class (yes, I took that from another review, ha ha)
    The verdict,, the missing past videos is inexcusable-I've joined some sites in my day; and I can say that this is one of the few times I didn't get my moneys worth this time around.

  • Comment by: BigBob (update)

    Score: 30% Date: 05/19/2013

    All the updates are now old shoots passed off as new. All the old downloadable content is gone. I guess they now have enough old scenes to post a new for a couple of years. I assume this means there will never be any new scenes. The blog and Q and A with the guy that shoots these is gone, which also suggests to be some big, and probably not good changes. One more thing, I cant be sure, but to me it appears the dates on the updates get switched around. This means you dont always get a "new" aka old scene every week (I could be wrong about this.

    But the upside is that the scenes that nare available are great, just not many of them compared with last year, and none can be downloaded. Too bad, was once THE best site

  • Comment by: BigBob

    Score: 50% Date: 02/15/2013

    Was a really great site, but there have been some big changes lately. There used to be a large amount of content, and a regular blog, so you knew when new scenes would be added. A new scene was added every week. This all changed a few months ago. Initially the excuse was a hard drive crash, and scenes were being reshot. Fair enough, it happens. Then all the old content disappeared, leaving maybe 30 or 40 more recent scenes (my estimate is another 100? vanished). Now three months after the "hard drive crash" and there have only been a couple of new scenes, and for the last two weeks its been OLD scenes uploaded as "new". All blogs have stopped. Who knows what is really going on and if its going back to the way it use to be. Finally, its no longer possible to download content. I hope this all gets resolved, as it really was one of the best sites I've subscribed to (deserves 90/100). When my current membership period is up, I wont be renewing unless this gets fixed.

  • Comment by: Teddy

    Score: 20% Date: 11/18/2012

    This was once a great site with stellar customer service. Saddly this is no longer the case. Current films are not downloadable and customer service is non existent.

  • Comment by: ML

    Score: 1% Date: 10/30/2012

    He never shows his face. Yes, sometimes you wanna see who the dude is that is filming and fucking. All the other sites do. Plus, he sometimes establishes their age, but these definitely aren't first timers as advertised as so many guys on here have said. I guess he doesn't want to show his face, for fear of someone seeing him on the street and calling him a fat (literally fat, the dude is obese) LIAR.

  • Comment by: Josh

    Score: 90% Date: 01/11/2012

    I love this site! There's only one girl on here that I've seen elsewhere (Jada Stevens). I especially love the various MILFs that this site has shown; they really do seem like they could be one's next-door neighbor, and they're also a nice contrast to the PYTs.

    Given that it updates once a week, I renew my membership every year for a month and download the updates. Question: is this site still active? There have not been any new models listed on the front page in a few months.

  • Comment by: Ted

    Score: 90% Date: 04/17/2011

    Really Beautiful Amateur Girls. Nicely shot.

    One complaint: the video aspect ratio keeps changing from video to video.

  • Comment by: ff

    Score: 90% Date: 04/10/2011

    This site is a really good one. Its biggest strength is the models. Some you might have seen around other sites, but I would say half are first timers, you can tell how nervous they are before they start. Good variety, from one on one, to group sex, even a 8 guy bang. Only qualm is that the guys talk way TOO damn much, almost like COHF or tampa bukkake too much. Good number of the first timers seemed to be talked into returning.

  • Comment by: vv9vv

    Score: 80% Date: 03/26/2011

    met this petite lil dominican ass Hoe at one of the local hoe Bars. Shes 27 years old, with 5 kds. I could not even tell this bitch was that old. She looked about 20 & has a bangin body, with a Little Plump dominican Booty. This lil dominican pussy hoe can shake her ass. She can almost shake it like a black women. I

  • Comment by: DeanH

    Score: 91% Date: 09/29/2009

    Hmmm, this is my favorite site ever.... right now anyway :-) Surprised by the other comment above. These are some of the most real and intense scenes out there. Without being illegal of course. I suppose some of the Euro sites are more intense but for a US site, this is the best I've found to date. Deep throat, spanking, anal, swallowing, facials. But the best part, I recognized only two girls from other sites. All the rest seem to be real amateur first-timers, which I really like. The girls have that "deer in headlights" look before the scene begins. I fucking love that. Then, the guy pretty much has his way with them but at the same time, he makes sure they have fun too and works hard to make sure they have a real orgasm. He definitely could use more pics but I think he must have heard that from others cuz lately every scene comes with a pic zip set. He's obviously no pro photographer but the pics are decent.

    Anyway, just my 2 cents. I'd give it a 100 but I'm holding that for the first site to get Angelina Jolie fucking on camera. :-)
    Reply from RabbitsReviews (Date:09/30/2009): Aren't we all...

  • Comment by: Harvey Schmutz

    Score: 70% Date: 07/02/2009

    Signed-up from interest in real amateur ladies who in trailer videos looked pretty good. Was very easy to download their 30-minute or so segments as one file. Most scenes had a blow job followed by a break and then regular sex on a bed filmed POV-style. But latest updates had nice ladies wearing bird wings and stuff like that just didn't fit. When my month was over I didn't feel it was worth the cost and deleted all the downloads from my system only a couple of weeks later. They just didn't turn me on like I expected it would. Most of the girls were right around 20 and looked it. He should broaden out into older MILF/Mature ladies of which he had only a couple and they looked pretty good. I look for a photo session where I can fantasize about meeting a prostitute or girlfriend, we get acquainted while wearing our clothes over a few minutes, strip, and do what we're there to do. This guy comes closer than many to that, but his scenes just don't have the intensty I would expect in such a sexy encounter. I would not subscribe again.