As the song says, "If all your exes lived in Texas, you'd probably hang your hat in Tennessee." Well, if all your exes were on the Internet, there's a good chance you'd find them at Your Ex Girlfriends. From seriously hot to extremely average, they have assembled content of "girlfriends, wives and ordinary people."
There are 74 videos available on YourExGirlfriends at this point and I can gaurentee you that most, if not all, of them are nonexclusive. For example, the video that is supposedly of a dude filming his girlfriend, but he has to ask her what her name is. Or the video that ends with the chick looking at the camera and giving the name of a different site/company. Even though the bitrates technically give you great quality, the movies generally translates into only average quality when played on your computer.
Currently, they have 370 sets of pics of amateur babes. Some of them are naked, others are not. Since they've said that they have poached a bunch of these pics from elsewhere on the Internet they're probably not very exclusive, but there's a good chance that most of the ones sent in by members are. Most of the sets have about 10 pictures each, but there are a lot where you will find only two or three. The quality of the pictures ranges from very poor quality to high res.
The members' area of this site is fairly busy, but it's easy enough to find what you want. They also have a very simple search engine that will allow you to search for specific content by one term only, such as age or race.
Bonus content includes many pages of videos from a bunch of extra sites, some with a similar amateur focus. They do seem to update their main content a couple of times a week, but these days it is mostly just vids being added. Your Ex Girlfriends isn't a great place for true made-at-home video action, but the amateur content and the many bonuses aren't a bad way to spend some time.