I Know That Girl bills itself as the home to 100% real amateur girlfriends whose sexual escapades have been caught on camera and submitted to the site by ex, or soon to be ex, boyfriends, just for a little cash payout. That sounds rather scandalous, doesn't it? I bet those chicks are really pissed!
On the other hand, after having spent some time on the site I would instead call IKnowThatGirl as the home to 100% real amateur and professional pornstars whose tapes were submitted with their full knowledge and consent and that they knew exactly what they were making the movie for. In the end, there aren't any nasty surprises happening here.
So the content isn't true amateur girlfriend action, but at least there is a lot of it, right? There are 234 videos with corresponding high-res photos and with the weekly updating, it's still growing. Each of the movies comes in a few file types, including a gorgeous Windows Media and MP4 option with high-def playback. You'll also find various versions compatible with portable devices, including 3GPs for older mobiles. You can stream most of the video files as well.
They really make an attempt to make the whole betrayed GF premise believable. The actors try to come across as genuine couples. There are often some shots taken from a camera put on a dresser or something by the dude to make it seem like real homemade porn. Still, the use of some very recognizable pornstars who are pros at fucking on cam will ruin the illusion for many of you (some of the members' comments made reference to that exact thing).
Before you head off, let me tell you about the bonuses. Your membership gets you access to the entire Mofos Network of 13 sites, like Teens At Work and MILFs Like It Black. Just keep in mind that although most of them are still updating, at least a couple of them aren't growing anymore.
When sifting through all the content here and across the network, you can save your favorites, leave comments and rate the content. Then you can sort by those ratings whether you're looking only at this site's scenes or those from across the network. Too bad there's no advanced search, though. As it continues to grow, I Know That Girl is only getting better.
* Please include a pro and a con about the site. Balance is essential in making a comment worthwhile. Scores without comments will be deleted.
* Watch out for ratings of zero and 100. In our opinion, there is no such thing as a site that is absolutely perfect or completely worthless.