What I did see on HomePornoTapes is some great-quality amateur porn. I am always a little hesitant to believe these sites that claim the content is really made-at-home stuff sent in by members, but based on the episodes I checked out it isn't that hard to believe.
Except for a couple of scenes in which a third party was filming, the rest of the episodes were all shot POV or tripod and had a very amateur/made-at-home look and feel. Also, the video quality is great and each scene can be downloaded in clips or in one nice full-length Windows Media file.
There are 80 episodes at this point and while most are dude-dame straight couple fuck scenes, there are also a few lesbian episodes. Updating isn't clear, but based on the numbers and some research I did, they look to be averaging about one update every two weeks. There are photo sets, but they are just sets of vid caps.
Site navigation is simple and straightforward, but they do something with their bonuses that I find frustrating. Throughout the pages of content they place ads for the bonus sites. Normally this would just be a little annoying, but in this case it is more than that. Since you only get access to all the bonus sites as long as you remain a member (one site is made available each month) these bonus site links actually take you to the site, so you can sign up and pay for a membership.
Considering what you get, the price tag is a little high. Taking that into account, along with the initial lack of bonus sites, means that while the amateur porn looks great, it isn't as easy to recommend Home Porno Tapes as it could have been had the price been lower and the number of bonus sites been higher.