Next Door Gay doesn't exactly live up to what the name entails. You'd probably be inclined to think of it being a purely amateur site, but its nonexclusive content is often culled from porno DVDs with pornstar pros, not nameless gays or straights getting it on. That said, much of the footage sampled is what you might call classic, as it comes from the late eighties and early nineties. There are a few scenes that do fit into the true amateur realm of things, but these seem the exception rather than the rule.

The 55 galleries all seem to offer high-res images. Some sets are small with only about 30 pics, while others are much larger with over 125 frames. There are some hardcore layouts, but there are many more solo scenarios. This picture section has fewer blatantly recognizable pornstars of yesteryear, but the guys featured still tend not to come across as true amateurs. There's plenty of Czech musclemen shown for example, which always have that pro model look, even if they're not real smut celebs.

The 187 videos download in several formats, such as average-quality Windows Media clips, MPEGs with stellar-looking playback, as well as again, average-quality, MP4s that can be used in portable devices, such as iPods and PSPs. As mentioned previously, which bears reiterating, many of the vids come from vintage gay porn movies. If the stars are unfamiliar to some fans, it isn't because they're amateurs, it's merely because the content is so old school that you might have forgotten all about some of these once well-known studs by now.

There are four full-access bonus sites: Banging Black Gays, Shes A Shemale, They Go Both Ways and Insane Cock Gays. Main content appears to be updated on a weekly basis. I would say that besides nothing being exclusive, the biggest issue for some men would be that much of the stuff shown is so dated, with very few clips sampled from more recent releases. Next Door Gay is an okay, nonexclusive, high-quality site, but only if you can appreciate mostly vintage (post condom age) gay porn.