Almost everything about FudgeStick feels amateurish (and I don't necessarily mean that as a negative). Site design is fine and serves its purpose, but it certainly isn't slick. The chicks themselves aren't glossy pornstar babes, but rather the type of sexy chicks that you might pass in the street or try to take home from a club.
The scenes are also amateur in their production. While some have pathetic reality setups, other scenes get right to the action. Actually, even the reality ones take only a minute to get going after some awkward editing and a couple lines of dialogue. It's almost as if the guys making the movies are just as anxious as we are to get to the fucking and just want to hurry things along. The sucking and fucking itself is good solid hardcore action and while I did find that the cameraman wasn't always doing his best work, overall things were good.
While the site design, women and scenes were all very amateur, the quality of the content was so much better than what you might expect. There are 44 episodes available so far and each one comes with a set of about 100 vid caps and a video downloadable in both good-quality Windows Media and QuickTime formats. My only big complaint here would be the fact that the movies are downloadable in short clips only.
When you sign up to get your membership you are told that you also get access to one other site called Thuggeracial. Fudge Stick is updating very infrequently and has only added four scenes in over a year. If you're interested in signing up, you might want to only do so for a month.