To answer that I have just spent some quality time surfing through ILoveYouMelanie and I am here to report that there is great potential here, but if Melanie is your only reason for joining I can't give it a high recommendation.
The reason for that comes down to just two factors: the high price tag and the amount of content available. There are 33 movies and 23 photo sets waiting for you at this time. The bad news is that there are only five more videos and one more picture set since the last time we were here and that was about six months ago.
The reason I said the site had potential is because the content that is available is really good. Melanie is one sexy, horny chick and the various episodes capture that in a variety of ways. There are solo scenes, behind-the-scenes scenes, softcore scenes, lesbo scenes, blowjob scenes and hardcore fuck scenes. The quality of the content is also great. The pictures are almost high-res and the videos are downloadable in a superb-quality Windows Media format.
So as much as Melanie will please, there is just not enough of her to justify the expensive price tag. However, your membership does get you access to 19 other sites like I Love You Mya, Attack My Ass and Only The Biggest and all of them put together might justify the membership fee. There are more horny-babe sites, as well as numerous sites covering various niches from black chicks to old ladies to lesbians to anal sex.
The network itself is still updating all the time so join if the high-quality variety appeals to you. However, I Love You Melanie really needs to grow more before her fans will feel justified in dropping the cash just for her.