My Guy Cream Pie

Full Review

Will Peters 

By: Will Peters
Number of Reviews: 1381
Average Score: 65

We no longer link to this site.

My Guy Cream Pie claims to be 100 percent exclusive. However, as is so often the case, the content can be seen elsewhere within its network of sites. You'll see many of the same performers in the different shoots. They still have an amateur appeal, even if they can't be called newcomers.

MyGuyCreamPie has 23 Full HD videos. However, that's not a lot and despite the dates, we now know that they haven't added anything new since at least 2009. In other words, they're more than likely rotating the content, especially since the collection is smaller this visit.

You'll really enjoy the hot blowjobs and raw penetration. Seeing a naked pole sliding in and out of an exposed hole until it shoots a load of creamy goo that drips out of that rectal rosebud is intense in a way that safe sex or even bare backing without an internal cumshot can't compare. You won't want to miss seeing even one drop of that sperm as it oozes out of a well-fucked butt.

The guys are my kind of hot, too. Even though many are slender and hairless, there are some with a bit of body fuzz. Quite a few have more meat on their bones, so I can relate more to their bodies. They have that average-guy appeal. You will also see some muscular fellows who have that typical gay pornstar bod.

In addition to the many young amateurs, you'll also see some mature men with a bit more experience spilling their spunk into another guy's ass. For example, there's an interracial matchup with a white guy named Mitch Brawn who they call a DILF. He stars with a hung black guy named Tyrese who plugs his tight, white ass with his massive ebony rod.

You can see it in a hot video, but it is also in one of the 23 photo sets that happens to be one with high-res images. They come in a Zip file, so be sure to check them out.

There are 11 gay bonus sites, including No Condom Zone, Hammer VIP, Kyle Videos and Man Solos. Some of the others give you bisexual porn. You will also have access to a large archive of gay streaming DVDs. My Guy Creampie has some very sexy anal creampies, but too little content to get excited about. The theme-related bonus content does add to its appeal, though.

Member Area Screenshots

  • Screenshot 1
  • Screenshot 2
  • Screenshot 3
  • Screenshot 4

Write Your Review

* Please include a pro and a con about the site. Balance is essential in making a comment worthwhile. Scores without comments will be deleted.

* Watch out for ratings of zero and 100. In our opinion, there is no such thing as a site that is absolutely perfect or completely worthless.

Remaining characters: