Amateurs Do It
I have to say that when you see amateur straight porn, it sometimes makes you realize why not everyone is a pornstar. A lot of hetero guys seem to have performance anxiety. However, when you see gay porn sites like Amateurs Do It, many gays seem to be naturals when it comes to performing on camera. It also probably helps that with more than one dick in a flick or a pic if one lacks a bit of hardness another one is sure to pick up the slack, so there aren't any awkward lulls.
With that logic in mind, AmateursDoIt has a good number of group-sex scenes, so sometimes it will feel as if you're seeing wall-to-wall cock. However, as you'd expect on an amateur site, you will also see shyer men who prefer to perform solo rather than go hardcore with an audience. There are also couples who apparently are meeting for the first time, but seem to have such instant chemistry that they have no problem delivering onscreen passion.
Updates are on a weekly basis and you will find 220 high-def videos that can be streamed and downloaded as Flash and MP4s. They're also downloadable in Windows Media format. You can also download about 200 sets of high-res pics in Zip files and check them out in an automatic slideshow. Some of the galleries are broken up into parts and a handful contain only vid caps. You can rate the content, leave comments and save your favorites.
I like how you will see a mix of twinks, jocks and bears as well as everyday Joes who don't necessarily fit into any of those niches. I'm always happy to see a few men with piercings, tattoos and facial and body hair and there are a good number of those. I also saw Asian and ebony studs. Finding the performers and sex acts that I wanted would be easier if there was a search engine and/or keyword tags.
You get access to one bonus site, Wank Off World, and 18 or so gay hardcore feeds. There are sex stories and a section with member-submitted photos. Clearly these extras add value to your membership, but in my opinion they're not needed to make joining worthwhile. Amateurs Do It has enough HD vids and high-res pics to be worth your time and money.
* Please include a pro and a con about the site. Balance is essential in making a comment worthwhile. Score without comments will be deleted.
* Watch out for ratings of zero and 100. In our opinion, there is no such thing as a site that is absolutely perfect or completely worthless.