Number of Reviews: 1464
Average Score: 64
As a graying gay myself I very much appreciate the intergenerational action on Im Your Boy Toy. Granted, most of the dudes that are supposed to be "mature" are only in their late 20s or early to mid-30s, although there is at least one 52-year-old. Even so, you'll see a satisfying contrast between older-looking muscular hairy jocks and slim hairless twinks who look younger despite not necessarily being that much younger than the mature performers.
As I look at ImYourBoyToy today, I see they haven't added a new movie since January 2014. The collection is definitely a bit on the modest side when it comes to size. Still, they've included all kinds of navigational features that will come in handy when there's more to see here (which will take a while with the current growth rate). For example, you can save favorites and there's an advanced search. Also content can be rated and you can sort by overall ratings or just based on your personal ratings of the scenes.
Then when it comes to getting a closer look at any of the 58 videos you can check out detailed write-ups, keyword tags and check out other scenes from the same models. You can expect mostly high-def playback from the best of the MP4s and you can also stream these in an embedded Flash player, while there are also smaller MP4 files designed for portable devices. There are 32 photo sets to download in Zip files, too.
One of the hot scenes involves one of my favorite pornstars, Alexsander Freitas. He's a muscular, tattooed Brazilian. He pretty much dwarfs the twink Tyler Moss who bottoms for him in their scene together. Alexsander makes Tyler lick his sneakers and suck his fat cock before the little dude rides his swollen uncut member. Tyler actually ends up taking that thick dick in a number of positions, including face down from behind and doggy style, before ending up with his tiny butt covered in the buff daddy's jizz.
You get more Phoenixxx sites, including Bang Me Sugar Daddy. All of these bonuses definitely add value to your membership. All in all, Im Your Boy Toy isn't really big, but it is big enough to give it a chance.
* Please include a pro and a con about the site. Balance is essential in making a comment worthwhile. Scores without comments will be deleted.
* Watch out for ratings of zero and 100. In our opinion, there is no such thing as a site that is absolutely perfect or completely worthless.