Visit Samuel OToole

Full Review

Will Peters 

By: Will Peters
Number of Reviews: 1382
Average Score: 65

Money Back Guarantee
If you're not completely satisfied within three days of joining this site, email us and we'll ensure that you get your money back! (Note: Does not apply to accepted cross sales.)

Samuel OToole shot his first scene on camera in February 2010. He's a charming fellow who makes it clear that unlike a lot of pornstars, he isn't busy partying his ass off all the time. Instead, he's more like the guy-next-door who loves spending time out in nature around his Northern California home. Although the action definitely focuses on gay sex, Samuel seems to dig the ladies too.

Although the star of SamuelOToole made his debut not too long ago, his site is still considerably newer than that. However, it also looks like he has stopped udpating given that the amount of content hasn't changed in a long while. There are 102 videos and when it comes to the best of the MP4s, you're getting Full HD playback.

There is a mix of solo and hardcore action, including a few scenes with chicks and the rest with one, two or even three other guys. Samuel is muscular, has a decent-sized dick and sexy tattoos. I love that his body is proportionate, but he does work part-time as a personal trainer, so he knows how to build lean muscle on his 5'7" frame.

Seeing his hot bubble butt clench and release while he's trusting into a guy's ass or girl's pussy is quite the treat as is seeing his toned abs even when he's just jerking off alone. My favorite scene is a foursome with Sammy, redheaded James Jameson and bottoms Paul Wagner and Tyler Ford. I should also mention that some of the videos show you a more candid side to what's happening on set.

There are 72 photo galleries and some of them have high-res images. There are also Zip files. I really love some of the spreads, because Mr. O'Toole has some shots that definitely make me drool. For example, I love the layout where he poses in a red lace-up jockstrap. I also like the pics taken during his threesome with Zack Alexander and Nate Kennedy. I just love Zack's small, hairy super-toned body being used by the other two hotties.

As added enticement to join, you now get access to 13 more Next Door World network sites, including Tommy D XXX, Trystan Bull, Rod Daily and Marcus Mojo. The lack of updating is a big disappointment, but Samuel OToole does offer enough content that those interested in watching him work will find value in a membership.

Member Area Screenshots

  • Screenshot 1
  • Screenshot 2
  • Screenshot 3
  • Screenshot 4

Your membership includes

Write Your Review

* Please include a pro and a con about the site. Balance is essential in making a comment worthwhile. Scores without comments will be deleted.

* Watch out for ratings of zero and 100. In our opinion, there is no such thing as a site that is absolutely perfect or completely worthless.

Remaining characters: